top of page
Cover Image_FN 2

AN IMPOSSIBLE ASSIGNMENT

Nonprofits are asked to solve extraordinary problems without the infrastructure those problems demand.

I remember sitting in a board meeting toward the end of 2019, reviewing our first-year financials and finalizing our budget for 2020. I was panicked about money. By many measures, our nonprofit’s first year had been very successful. We had graduated our first cohort, with stories of personal growth, belonging, and entrepreneurial achievement that reminded us why we'd built the organization in the first place. Our restaurant had generated more than $300,000 in revenue—out of approximately $800,000 in total organizational revenue. Not bad for an 800-square-foot space. We'd attracted international media attention, including features by NowThis and Fast Company. And TIME magazine had named us one of the top 100 Greatest Places in the World. 

​

I had every reason to feel optimistic. And yet, sitting in that board meeting, looking at our projected $1 million+ in expenses for the coming year, I had no idea where most of that money was going to come from. The restaurant would generate revenue. I knew that much. But the rest? Would the donors who supported us in 2019 support us in 2020? Would any of the grants we had received come again? Would new foundations, new donors, find us? Beyond revenue from the restaurant, every single dollar felt like a question mark. And yet so many people trusted us, needed us, to find the funds. The pressure was overwhelming. So was the fear.

​

We had demonstrated that our work mattered. That our model was worth investing in. That people were paying attention. But none of that success seemed to translate into the predictable revenue required to sustain—and grow—the organization. And I remember thinking: Wow. This feels impossible.

Constrained by Design

The nonprofit sector is in crisis.¹ But not because it lacks talent, tenacity, and ingenuity. It’s in crisis because we’ve asked extraordinary people to do essential work inside a sector whose design no longer matches the scale or complexity of its assignment.

​

When I talk about design, I’m not suggesting that someone sat down with a master plan for the nonprofit sector as it exists today. The sector wasn’t designed all at once or according to a single blueprint. But it didn’t just magically emerge, either. Over generations, people have created the laws, policies, regulations, funding mechanisms, practices, and cultural expectations that govern how nonprofits form and function. These decisions were made across different eras, in response to different circumstances and priorities. Taken together, they have formed the architecture of today’s nonprofit sector.

 

This inherited architecture continues to shape—and too often constrain—what is possible.

​

The Work We’ve Asked Nonprofits To Do

Modern society has organized much of its work through three sectors: private, public, and nonprofit. Each plays a different role in how society functions. Markets organize much of our economic activity. Government establishes the rules, rights, and public goods on which society depends. And increasingly, nonprofits are where we turn when human needs exceed what markets will profitably provide and what government can—or chooses to—address.²

Three Sectors Infographic_Essay 2 (1).png

Over time, this configuration has left nonprofits carrying a profound responsibility. We ask them to protect civil rights, preserve culture, strengthen democracy, house people, support public health, educate children, restore ecosystems, welcome people home from incarceration, and respond to needs we haven't yet figured out how to solve anywhere else. In many cases, nonprofits aren't supplemental to our social infrastructure. They are our social infrastructure.

 

The Problems Are Enormous. The Capital Isn’t. 

The National Council of Nonprofits reports that 92 percent of charitable nonprofits spend less than $1 million annually while 88% spend less than $500,000.³ This statistic is often presented as a description of sector size. I think it deserves to be read not only as a warning sign, but also a design question. What does it say about our priorities that the organizations we rely on to confront some of society’s biggest challenges are, overwhelmingly, operating with remarkably little money? 

 

To be clear, being small isn’t, itself, the problem. After all, most businesses in America are small, too.⁴ But here’s the difference: We don't generally expect a small business operating on $500,000 a year to solve homelessness, reverse generational poverty, or alleviate food scarcity. Yet nonprofits of comparable economic scale are routinely asked to take on precisely these kinds of challenges.

​

So what does it mean to ask a $500,000 organization to take on a generational problem? What kind of wages can it pay? What benefits can it provide? How much can it invest in technology, operational infrastructure, leadership, research and development, or simply giving its people enough breathing room to think beyond next month?

​

This is not an argument that small organizations are ineffective. Some of the most powerful work in America happens inside small nonprofits, small businesses. And bigger isn’t inherently better. There are organizations whose missions are local, whose models work beautifully at a small scale, and whose leaders have no interest in becoming larger. 

​

Yet, when nearly nine out of ten nonprofits operate below $500,000 annually³—and more than nine out of ten below $1 million³—we are looking at an entire sector overwhelmingly made up of small organizations while asking that sector to shoulder a massive share of society's hardest work.³

​

And unlike in many conventional businesses, greater demand for a nonprofit's work does not generally produce greater revenue. More people needing housing does not automatically generate more money to build it. More families needing food does not automatically finance more meals. More people needing legal representation does not automatically pay for more lawyers. Demand often grows while the resources available to meet it do not.

Greater impact doesn't necessarily generate more capital, either. A nonprofit can continually achieve its mission without creating a corresponding stream of revenue to invest back into the organization. In my experience, many organizations operating between $100,000 and $500,000 aren't doing so because that’s the ideal budget for their mission—or because they couldn't put additional resources to powerful use. They're doing so, at least in part, because growing a nonprofit is exceptionally difficult.

​

The consequences of this mismatch cannot be ignored. Nonprofit Finance Fund's 2025 State of the Nonprofit Sector Survey found that 85 percent of respondents expected demand for their services to increase, while 52 percent had three months or less cash on hand and 36 percent had ended the previous year operating at a deficit—the highest share NFF had recorded in a decade. Only 41 percent reported being able to pay all full-time employees a living wage.⁵

​

In other words: the problems are getting bigger while many of the organizations we've asked to tackle them are becoming more financially fragile.

​

At some point, we have to confront the math. We cannot assign a sector many of society's largest problems without capital commensurate with the scale of the work we've asked it to do. Even essential nonprofits can fail inside poorly designed systems. And brilliant leaders can burn out inside impossible economic models.

​

An Open Invitation

The nonprofit sector will not rise to the level of our intentions. It will rise to the level of our design. It’s time to stop asking nonprofits to become leaner, scrappier, more collaborative, more innovative, more resilient—and start examining the untenable conditions we have asked them to work within. If the sector responsible for solving our greatest challenges were being designed today, from a blank sheet of paper, would we build it this way?

 

​

​

​

​

​

​

​

Notes & Sources

1. Center for Effective Philanthropy. A Sector in Crisis: How U.S. Nonprofits and Foundations Are Responding to Threats. 2026.

2. Emily Hunt Turner. Nonprofit Revolution. Presentation, University of St. Thomas Opus College of Business, May 2026.

3. National Council of Nonprofits. Nonprofit Impact Matters. 2019. Based on 2016 IRS Form 990 data.

4. U.S. Small Business Administration, Office of Advocacy. Frequently Asked Questions About Small Business 2026. February 2026.

5. Nonprofit Finance Fund. 2025 State of the Nonprofit Sector Survey: Essential, Enduring, and Under Strain. June 2025.


 

A Note on AI

I use AI as part of my creative process. Over the last year, AI has become a thought partner, a research assistant, an editor, and a visual designer. Here’s how I’ve deployed it here:

 

Field Notes is grounded in my personal experiences, observations, research, relationships, learnings, and ideas—all things I’ve developed and memorialized over the course of a decade building and leading in the nonprofit sector. I’ve used AI to augment this body of work in two primary ways: First, to help me organize years of notes and observations while pulling out themes, identifying alternative ways to present information, and offering differing or complementary points of view, backed by research. Second, to create imagery that matches my very picky design aesthetic. As a creative director, I’ve loved having a savvy assistant that can execute so swiftly. 

 

I am grateful for this remarkable tool—and, truthfully, still learning to understand its strengths and limitations. AI has made this work better. It has helped me see things I might have missed, question things I felt certain about, and express things I was still struggling to articulate. I want to give that contribution its credit. And I also believe authorship carries responsibility. The ideas and points of view I ultimately choose to put into the world are mine, and I take responsibility for everything I publish.

© 2026 by Emily Hunt Turner

​

bottom of page