SOCIAL ARCHITECT
![]() |
|---|
MISSING:
THE NONPROFIT BUSINESS SECTOR
What if the way we talk about nonprofits is limiting what we imagine for them?
Six years ago, I was at a local bank to deposit a check for our nonprofit when a teller asked, "Is this a business?" Another teller, familiar with our work, chimed in: "No. They're just a nonprofit." Just a nonprofit?
I couldn't stop thinking about that exchange. I still can't.
I was proud of our nonprofit identity; still am. But I hadn't considered that the designation might cause others to see our organization as something less. And I wasn't sure what bothered me more: the dismissiveness of just, or the suggestion that our nonprofit wasn't a business. What the hell?
We were incorporated. We had payroll, insurance, employee benefits, and an operational infrastructure to manage. We generated revenue, employed people, and were responsible for our bottom line. And unlike a traditional for-profit business, we didn't have just one bottom line. We had two. We were responsible for sustaining the business and delivering on our social mission. If anything, weren't we a business+?
I've long believed that language carries energy—that the words we choose don't simply describe the world, but help shape how we understand it. Brené Brown explores this idea in Atlas of the Heart, describing language as a portal to meaning-making and understanding.¹ Which makes me wonder: How much of what we believe about nonprofits is shaped by the language we use to describe them?
The Language We’ve Inherited
Once I started paying attention, I began noticing distinctions everywhere. Perhaps the most consequential is one so familiar that we rarely stop to question it: the business sector versus the nonprofit sector.
I've never had an issue with distinguishing nonprofits from for-profits. But somewhere along the way, we've moved from distinguishing nonprofit from for-profit to distinguishing nonprofit from business. And those are two very different distinctions. The first recognizes nonprofits as a different kind of business. The second suggests they aren't businesses at all.
The defining distinction between nonprofit and for-profit enterprises isn't that one is a business and the other isn't. It's how they're organized, what they're accountable to, and what they're permitted to do with the value they generate.
So why does this matter?
Before building and running a nonprofit, I would have said that it doesn’t. Now? I see the implications differently. In distinguishing nonprofits from businesses, we’ve created a cultural separation that doesn't reflect the actual complexity of operating a nonprofit. And that separation carries economic consequences. When we position nonprofits outside the world of business, we risk diminishing how their financial needs, operational capabilities, and potential are understood—and ultimately, how we're willing to invest in them.
The irony is that we reinforce this very distinction, often with the best of intentions. Over the last decade, I can't tell you how many times I've heard the phrase: Nonprofits need to operate more like businesses. I've even agreed with it. After all, nonprofits could benefit from stronger financial, operational, and predictive capabilities. But I've come to question the premise embedded in this directive. What if, before asking nonprofits to operate more like businesses, we started by recognizing them as businesses—and investing in them accordingly? For more on the economic conditions facing nonprofits, see Field Note 02: An Impossible Assignment.
I think back to my interaction with the bank teller. What frustrated me wasn't simply the exchange itself. It was the assumption that I sensed beneath it: that a nonprofit somehow occupied a different, perhaps lesser, position.
That said, my frustration wasn't only about perception. There are practical consequences to the language we’ve inherited and the distinctions we draw, too.
Nonprofits have statements of activities rather than traditional profit and loss (P&L) statements. Statements of financial position rather than balance sheets. Our leaders are often called Executive Directors rather than CEOs. We talk about fundraising rather than capitalization, capacity building rather than growth infrastructure, and overhead rather than capabilities.
Some of these distinctions are legally or technically necessary. Others are conventions we've inherited. And some reflect genuine differences in how nonprofit organizations are designed to operate. Collectively, however, they create something that feels like an entirely separate language—one that can introduce unnecessary friction between two similar worlds.
I remember experiencing this most acutely when working with board members, advisors, and outside professionals who brought valuable private-sector expertise. Conversations often required an extra layer of translation: Oh, right. The statement of financial position is essentially our balance sheet.
It wasn't an insurmountable obstacle. But it was friction. And I began wondering why we needed so much translation between two sectors that, despite their differences, share so many of the same operational responsibilities.
The problem, as I see it, isn't the existence of different terminology. It's the assumptions that have attached to those differences. Which makes me question what else might be getting lost in translation. Are we losing access to the very financial thinking, tools, and investment strategies that help for-profit enterprises grow and endure? Does today’s nonprofit language obscure the value nonprofits create—and the possibility that this value could be responsibly monetized to advance their missions?
The Language That’s Missing
If we don't recognize nonprofits as businesses, what kinds of business capabilities are we overlooking as necessary—or even appropriate—to invest in?
Take research and development (R&D).
In the private sector, R&D is a familiar investment in a company's future. Businesses devote resources to testing new products, technologies, markets, and operating models. Not every experiment succeeds. That's understood. The investment is just as much about developing the capacity to learn, adapt, and evolve.
R&D exists in the nonprofit sector, particularly among large organizations engaged in scientific and medical research. But I'm interested in R&D among the 88% of nonprofits operating on less than $500,000 annually.² These are the organizations I keep coming back to—the vast majority of nonprofits doing extraordinary work in their communities, often with limited resources. How many of them have a dedicated R&D budget?
And I don't just mean researching a new program or evaluating an existing one. I mean R&D for the organization itself: testing revenue models and business lines, developing leadership pipelines, exploring shared operating capabilities, or discovering how AI could change the economics of nonprofit operating models. Given the complexity of the challenges these organizations confront, shouldn't they have meaningful resources to develop how they operate and evolve?
Yet in my experience, dedicated R&D budgets among smaller, community-based nonprofits are exceedingly uncommon. This isn't to suggest that research and development doesn't happen in these organizations. It does. But it's rarely recognized, budgeted for, or invested in as such. Instead, it relies on the ingenuity and grit of people whose capacity to innovate is already constrained by the demands of keeping their organizations running.
And R&D is just one example. What about long-term capitalization, financial modeling, market development, or strategic reserves? These are familiar concepts in the for-profit world, yet how often do they enter our conversations about building and sustaining smaller nonprofits?
An Open Invitation
Nonprofits don't need to become businesses. They've been businesses all along. And I love that the nonprofit sector is different. Its distinct purpose, structure, and obligations are worth celebrating. But somewhere along the way, I fear that different has become synonymous with less than. And this unspoken perception continues to cost the us .
I don't know how much of the nonprofit sector's economic architecture can be traced to language. And I don't believe changing terminology alone will change the underlying system. But I do believe the way we talk about, and understand, nonprofits influences what we imagine is possible for them—and what we're willing to invest in making possible.
What if we recognized nonprofits more consistently as businesses designed to create social value that benefits us all? Would financial leadership, technology, marketing, R&D, and operating infrastructure begin to look less like expenses to minimize and more like capabilities worth investing in?
__________________________
Notes & Sources
1. Brown, Brené. (2021). Atlas of the Heart: Mapping Meaningful Connection and the Language of Human Experience. Random House, p. xxi.
2. National Council of Nonprofits. Nonprofit Impact Matters. 2019. Based on 2016 IRS Form 990 data.
A Note on AI
I use AI as part of my creative process. Over the last year, AI has become a thought partner, a research assistant, an editor, and a visual designer. Here’s how I’ve deployed it here:
Field Notes is grounded in my personal experiences, observations, research, relationships, learnings, and ideas—all things I’ve developed and memorialized over the course of a decade building and leading in the nonprofit sector. I’ve used AI to augment this body of work in two primary ways: First, to help me organize years of notes and observations while pulling out themes, identifying alternative ways to present information, and offering differing or complementary points of view, backed by research. Second, to create imagery that matches my very picky design aesthetic. As a creative director, I’ve loved having a savvy assistant that can execute so swiftly.
I am grateful for this remarkable tool—and, truthfully, still learning to understand its strengths and limitations. AI has made this work better. It has helped me see things I might have missed, question things I felt certain about, and express things I was still struggling to articulate. I want to give that contribution its credit. And I also believe authorship carries responsibility. The ideas and points of view I ultimately choose to put into the world are mine, and I take responsibility for everything I publish.
